The Objectivism Reference CenterHome  Rand's Books  Other Books  Magazines  Texts  Biography  Forums  Websites  Critics  Miscellaneous  Search  Email Us
You Are Here: Home > Texts > Branden on Capital Punishment
Stuck in another site's frames? Escape!

Branden Excerpt: On Capital Punishment

The following excerpt is from the "Intellectual Ammunition Department" column in the January 1963 issue of The Objectivist Newsletter, p. 3. Nathaniel Branden responds to the question, "What is the Objectivist stand on capital punishment?":

In considering this issue, two separate aspects must be distinguished: the moral and the legal.

[...]

[Regarding] the legal question: Should a legal system employ capital punishment? [...] There are grounds for debate -- though not out of sympathy or pity for murderers.

If it were possible to by fully and irrevocably certain, beyond any possibility of error, that a man were guilty, then capital punishment for murder would be appropriate and just. But men are not infallible; juries make mistakes; that is the problem. There have been instances recorded where all the available evidence pointed overwhelmingly to a man's guilt, and the man was convicted, and then subsequently discovered to be innocent. It is the possibility of executing an innocent man that raises doubts about the legal advisability of capital punishment. It is preferable to sentence ten murderers to life imprisonment, rather than sentence one innocent man to death. If a man is unjustly imprisoned and subsequently proven to be innocent, some form of restitution is still possible; none is possible if he is dead.

The problem involved is that of establishing criteria of proof so rationally stringent as to forbid the possibility of convicting an innocent man.

All emphasis was in the original. Editorial insertions are shown in brackets. Omissions from the text are shown with bracketed ellipses. All other punctuation and spelling is from the original.


About the Objectivism Reference Center

The philosophy of Ayn Rand, a twentieth-century novelist and philosopher, is known as Objectivism. The Objectivism Reference Center provides resources about Rand, her ideas, her works, and places where those are discussed and debated. Visit the Site Information page for details on site policies. Suggestions for additional materials or additional links are welcomed.

If you have questions, comments or corrections related to this page, email the webmaster. If JavaScript is enabled for your browser, you can check to see when this page was last modified.

Copyright © 1999-2009 by Richard Lawrence. All rights reserved.

Home  Rand's Books  Other Books  Magazines  Texts  Biography  Forums  Websites  Critics  Miscellaneous  Search  Email Us